Blog

ICE Gets a New Boss Because the Old Pace Wasn't Fast Enough

by Václav immigration ice

There is a very Washington move available whenever a number refuses to move the way you promised it would: you don't fix the process, you fire the person standing next to it. ICE just got the treatment.

Kenneth Genalo, the acting head of Enforcement and Removal Operations — the branch that actually does the arresting and deporting — is out, framed as a retirement, per CBS News. Robert Hammer, who ran Homeland Security Investigations, is being reassigned. Replacing them: Marcos Charles and Derek Gordon, both career ICE hands, alongside a reported dozen more local leadership swaps that could pull in Customs and Border Protection officials to backfill.

The stated reason isn't subtle. Stephen Miller set a target of at least 3,000 arrests a day — a number that, run out over a year, would blow past a million. Border czar Tom Homan's own quote in the CBS piece says it plainly: "The numbers are good... But it's not good enough." Translation: the metric came from the top, the agency couldn't hit it, and the org chart absorbed the consequence instead of the target.

  • The goal: 3,000 arrests per day, north of a million deportations in year one.
  • The obstacle: ICE has been prioritizing "worst of the worst" cases, which by design is a slower, one-by-one process.
  • The fix, so far: new names in the enforcement chain, not a new theory of how you square a mass-scale quota against a targeted, evidence-heavy process.

Here's the part worth sitting with if you're the skeptical-of-government type, regardless of which administration is doing the reorganizing: swapping out the people running an agency is the easiest lever any White House has, and it is very often pulled precisely because the harder levers — actual court capacity, actual staffing, actual due process at scale — take years and money that nobody wants to admit is the real bottleneck. A new director doesn't add judges to the docket or beds to a detention system. It just changes whose name is on the memo when next quarter's number still comes in short.

I'd love to be wrong about this one. Genalo and Hammer might have genuinely been the drag on the system, and Charles and Gordon might get to 3,000 a day through nothing but sharper management. But the pattern — set an unrealistic number, miss it, blame the personnel, repeat — is one this town runs on both sides of the aisle, on both sides of just about every issue. It rarely ends with the number getting hit. It usually just ends with a different name getting blamed next time.

← Back to Blog